Best Infant Car Seats for Small Cars

Best Infant Car Seats for Small Cars

Car seats are a necessity when you bring a little baby into your family. However, not all car seats are suitable for every type of car; some are simply too big. Knowing this is a common problem, I have compiled a list of the best infant car seats for small cars.

Types of Car Seats

Choose the right type of car seat for your baby's age

Choose the right type of car seat for your baby's age (Source: Peanut Butter Fingers)

You have two main car seat styles to choose from: infant carrier or convertible. The type you choose is up to you.

➡️The infant carrier car seat is the type you see a lot with newborns. There is a carrier that the baby is buckled into that locks into a base that stays in the car. These can be very useful when your baby falls asleep in the car; you definitely don’t want to wake a sleeping baby.

However, the carriers can be very heavy and cumbersome as your baby grows heavier.

➡️Convertible car seats are nice because most models can take your baby from infancy right through toddlerhood. They can be installed facing the rear or front and with removable padding, you can rest easy knowing your newborn is secure and safe.

However, you may regret your purchase when you have to transfer your sleeping baby from the car seat to the stroller.

The Best Car Seat Set-Up

The car seat should installed in the middle seat for maximum safety

The car seat should installed in the middle seat for maximum safety (Source: Car Seat Blog)

Oftentimes, you will find car seats set up on either side of the vehicle, usually in the rear seat on the passenger’s side so the parent/driver can reach back if needed. However, this is not the safest location for your baby’s car seat for several reasons.

It may not be the most convenient for you, but the rear middle seat is the best place for your baby’s car seat. In the middle seat, your baby is further away from the doors keeping them safer in the event of a side impact crash. In addition, without the back of the car seat against the front seat, there is less risk of the baby being crushed in a front or rear crash.

You also want to make sure you use the LATCH system to install your car seat rather than the seat belt. Seat belts, particularly those that lock, can be safe, but it’s better to anchor the car seat for a more secure installation.

How to Choose the Best Infant Car Seats for Small Cars?

☑️Rear-Facing

Whichever style of car seat you choose, you want to make sure it has the option to be installed rear-facing. This is the safest orientation for babies up until about the age of 2 (or whenever they outgrow the rear-facing position).

☑️Secure Installation

Using LATCH system is crucial to choose Best Infant Car Seats for Small Cars

Install your car seat using the LATCH system (Source: Car Seats for the Littles)

As mentioned previously, your car seat should be installed via LATCH system for the most securely anchored installation. Some car seats have additional features that build on the LATCH system to make it even more fool-proof and secure.

☑️Easy to Clean

You can count on your car seat getting dirty; kids are notorious for spilling mountains of crumbs in their car seats. Thankfully, many car seats come with removable liners, and some are even machine-washable making it easier for you to keep it clean.

☑️Compact

Some car seats are narrow enough to fit three across in your car

Some car seats are narrow enough to fit three across in your car (Source: Amazon UK)

Since the topic is “car seats for small cars” (like the Toyota Corolla), you, of course, want to make sure your car seat is compact. This means it should be somewhat small in both width (about 18”) and depth (about 20-25”) in order to fit into your car comfortably.

☑️Weight Limit

Infant car seats only last so long, but some convertible car seats don’t work for infants. It’s important to do your research to make sure the car seat you choose fits your child’s size and weight.

☑️Protection

There should be plenty of safety cushion and layers in your car seat

There should be plenty of safety cushion and layers in your car seat (Source: PR Newswire)

There should be plenty of safety cushion and layers in your car seat 

You need to find a car seat that has been tested for every type of crash imaginable. This includes side-impact, head-on, rear-end, and rollover. The car seat should have plenty of padding as well as a strong frame to keep your baby safe.

☑️Cost

The car seat you choose should be cost effective especially if you end up needing a second car seat down the road. Babies grow out of infant carriers quickly; you don’t want to spend a fortune on something that will only last a few months. However, don’t skimp on quality to save a little bit of money.

Top-Rated Car Seats for Small Cars

Preview
Chicco KeyFit 30 Infant Car Seat, Orion
Recommend for Convertible
Safety 1st Guide 65 Convertible Car Seat, Chambers
Britax B-Safe 35 Infant Car Seat, Black
Recommend for Carrier
Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 Convertible Car Seat, Black Gravel
Title
Chicco KeyFit 30 Infant Car Seat, Orion
Safety 1st Guide 65 Convertible Car Seat, Chambers
Britax B-Safe 35 Infant Car Seat, Black
Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 Convertible Car Seat, Black Gravel
Weight Capacity
4-30 lbs
5-40 lbs (rear-face); 22-65 lbs (front-face)
4-35 lbs
9-40 lbs (rear-face); 22-70 lbs (front-face)
Dimensions
17.32″ x 14.96″ x 27.95″
20″ x 18″ x 23.5″
17.75” x 25” x 26.5”
22.8″ x 21.2″ x 29.5″
Installation
SuperCinch tightener for LATCH system
LATCH or seat belt
Safe Center LATCH or seat belt lock-offs
LATCH or seat belt
Protection
Energy-absorbing EPS foam
Side-impact protection
2 layers of side protection, steel frame, SafeCell impact technology
Air Protect advanced cushioning system
Prime
Price
from $189.99
from $67.88
$168.00
$212.49
Preview
Chicco KeyFit 30 Infant Car Seat, Orion
Title
Chicco KeyFit 30 Infant Car Seat, Orion
Weight Capacity
4-30 lbs
Dimensions
17.32″ x 14.96″ x 27.95″
Installation
SuperCinch tightener for LATCH system
Protection
Energy-absorbing EPS foam
Prime
Price
from $189.99
Recommend for Convertible
Preview
Safety 1st Guide 65 Convertible Car Seat, Chambers
Title
Safety 1st Guide 65 Convertible Car Seat, Chambers
Weight Capacity
5-40 lbs (rear-face); 22-65 lbs (front-face)
Dimensions
20″ x 18″ x 23.5″
Installation
LATCH or seat belt
Protection
Side-impact protection
Prime
Price
from $67.88
Preview
Britax B-Safe 35 Infant Car Seat, Black
Title
Britax B-Safe 35 Infant Car Seat, Black
Weight Capacity
4-35 lbs
Dimensions
17.75” x 25” x 26.5”
Installation
Safe Center LATCH or seat belt lock-offs
Protection
2 layers of side protection, steel frame, SafeCell impact technology
Prime
Price
$168.00
Recommend for Carrier
Preview
Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 Convertible Car Seat, Black Gravel
Title
Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 Convertible Car Seat, Black Gravel
Weight Capacity
9-40 lbs (rear-face); 22-70 lbs (front-face)
Dimensions
22.8″ x 21.2″ x 29.5″
Installation
LATCH or seat belt
Protection
Air Protect advanced cushioning system
Prime
Price
$212.49

1

Chicco KeyFit 30

Sale
Chicco KeyFit 30 Infant Car Seat, Orion
257 Reviews
Chicco KeyFit 30 Infant Car Seat, Orion
  • The #1-rated infant car seat in America!
  • Easiest to install with Recline Sure levelling foot, Ride Right bubble levels, and Super Cinch LATCH tightened
  • Designed for travel system use with compatible Chicco strollers (sold separately)

The Chicco KeyFit 30 is currently the #1 rated car seat on the market and for good reason.

It has some great safety features. The SuperCinch tightener ensures a tight LATCH fit with the pull of a single strap making installation a breeze. It is also made with energy-absorbing EPS foam to keep your baby safe in the event of a crash.

You can use this car seat from birth with the included infant insert. This helps to keep your baby’s head in the right position and fits babies from 4 to 11 pounds.

There is a multi-position canopy to keep your baby protected from the sun on your long drives or outings in the stroller (with travel system base).

The car seat itself is also a bit heavier (estimating between 10-12 pounds based on the total weight minus the base) and only handles up to 30 pounds of baby weight.

PROS

  • SuperCinch tightener
  • check
    Leveling foot and bubble indicator on the base
  • The seat pad is machine-washable

CONS:

  • The car seat is quite heavy
  • Only suitable up to 30 pounds

2

Safety 1st Guide 65

Sale
Safety 1st Guide 65 Convertible Car Seat, Chambers
1,169 Reviews
Safety 1st Guide 65 Convertible Car Seat, Chambers
  • The guide 65 is a perfect fit for smaller cars and helps protect your child longer in both rear and forward facing positions
  • Rear-facing 5-40 pounds and 19"-40"
  • Forward-facing 22-65 pounds and 34"-52"

Safety 1st is known for their affordable baby products, and the Guide 65 car seat is no exception. This car seat is available for a price point just about any family can afford.

This is a convertible car seat, which means it can be used both rear-facing and front-facing. Able to used rear-facing from birth (5 pounds), you shouldn’t need to buy another seat for your child until they are ready for a booster seat since this one supports up to 65 pounds and has an adjustable headrest.

The Guide 65 is one of the best car seats for small cars. In fact, it’s so narrow (18”) that they claim you can fit three right across your back seat if you needed. However, be sure to measure your back seat as many have said that three did not end up fitting in their vehicle.

The seat is all one piece and can be installed via LATCH system or seat belt. Many have said that this car seat is a bit difficult to install, specifically when tightening the strap for the LATCH system. The car seat seems to fit loosely making it less safe.

PROS

  • Affordable
  • check
    Rear and front-facing
  • Supports up to 65 pounds
  • check
    Narrow

CONS:

  • May not be able to fit 3 across
  • Hard to tighten strap for LATCH

3

Britax B-Safe 35

Britax B-Safe 35 Infant Car Seat, Black
106 Reviews
Britax B-Safe 35 Infant Car Seat, Black
  • Surrounded in safety: A layer of side impact protection, steel frame, and impact absorbing base
  • Easy installation: Use Safe Center LATCH or built-in seat belt lock-offs to secure the infant car seat
  • Relax & Recline: Spring-assisted recline and indicators ensure the best vehicle installation angle

If you are looking for the safest car seat for your small car, you want the Britax B-Safe 35.

Just by looking at this car seat, you can tell that this Britax Car Seat is made well and extremely safe. With a steel frame, 2 layers of side impact protection, SafeCell impact technology, and an impact-absorbing base you know your baby is safe and secure.

This car seat is easy to install with the Safe Center LATCH system or built-in seat belt lock-offs. The base is also adjustable with spring-assisted recline for comfort and proper installation.

The B-Safe 35 has a small frame (only 17.75” wide and 26.5” deep), and the smart contoured shape takes up very little space in the car,

Despite its small size, it is still pretty heavy (11.5 pounds) most likely due to the steel frame. Being narrow also means that your baby may outgrow it before they even reach the 35-pound weight limit.

The cover is removable for cleaning. Simply spot clean if there are any stains and allow it to drip dry.

PROS

  • Premium safety features
  • check
    Takes up little space in the car
  • Affordable

CONS:

  • Baby may outgrow the narrow seat quickly
  • Heavy

4

Maxi-Cosi Pria 70

Sale
Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 Convertible Car Seat, Black Gravel
560 Reviews
Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 Convertible Car Seat, Black Gravel
  • 2-IN-1 CONVERTIBLE CAR SEAT - Two modes of use: rear-facing car seat 9-40 pounds and forward-facing car seat 22-70 pounds.
  • SUPERIOR SIDE IMPACT PROTECTION - Designed by car seat safety experts, the patented Air Protect advanced cushioning system provides superior protection around your child's head. Tinyfit system has 3 harness shoulder heights is 5 inch at the lowest, 7 inch in the middle and 9 inch at the highest. Tinyfit insert is about 16 inch from the seat bottom to the top of the head area. The top of a childs head cannot exceed the top of the tinyfit insert
  • MACHINE WASHABLE FABRICS - The seat pad and harness covers are machine washable and removable with simple snaps. There's never a need to uninstall the seat or rethread the harness for cleaning.

The Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 convertible car seat has luxury written all over it with its premium fabrics and lush padding.

You can tell that this car seat is safe just by looking at it. There is plenty of padding with the Tinyfit insert for infants. There is also the Air Protect advanced cushioning system which keeps your baby safe in the event of a crash.

Though there is an infant insert, this car seat, unfortunately, is not recommended for babies under 9 pounds. This may be a deal breaker since most babies are born lighter than this (unless you have a big baby like I did).

Even though there is a minimum weight of 9 pounds for this car seat, it does support up to 70 pounds, which is sure to fit your little one right up until they are ready for a booster seat.

This car seat installs via LATCH or seat belt like most convertible car seats, but this one claims to be easier than most thanks to its shape which is reclined and contoured to fit your vehicle better.

PROS

  • Easier LATCH system
  • check
    Air Protect cushioning for safety
  • Supports up to 70 pounds

CONS:

  • 9-pound weight minimum
  • A little wider than others

5

Graco SnugRide SnugLock 35 Elite

Sale
Graco SnugRide SnugLock 35 Elite Infant Car Seat, Oakley
64 Reviews
Graco SnugRide SnugLock 35 Elite Infant Car Seat, Oakley
  • SnugLock Technology features a hassle-free 3-step installation rear-facing car seat helps protect infants from 4 - 35 lb and up to 32" quick and easy clean up with the Rapid Remove cover
  • Simply Safe Adjust Harness System adjusts headrest and harness together to prevent rethreading Safety Core absorbs frontal crash forces
  • Adjustable base with 4 recline positions and easy-to-read bubble level indicator InRight LATCH system for a one-second LATCH attachment

If it’s made by Graco, you know it’s good. They’ve been trusted by parents for years thanks to their commitment to quality, comfort, and safety.

This car seat has gone through rigorous safety testing. It is one of the top safety-recommended car seat models. It has been specially engineered and tested to meet US standard FMVSS 213 for child safety restraints.

The SnugRide Elite is one of the easiest to install thanks to the special SnugLock base feature. You can use this 3-step system to lock the base securely in place with just the car’s seat belt or you can install it with the LATCH system if you so desire.

The base is also adjustable, giving you 4 recline options to choose from to keep your baby comfortable and safe. There is also a bubble level indicator ensuring that your car seat is installed properly.

This car seat can be used from birth (4 pounds) with the infant insert that is included. It creates a snug fit, but some parents complain that it fits just a little too tight for comfort.

The large canopy is ideal for protecting your baby from the sun and prying eyes when you’re out and about. However, with the canopy open, it is nearly impossible to adjust or grab the handle.


Further read: Full Review of Graco SnugRide 35 Elite

PROS

  • Easy to install
  • check
    Safe
  • Adjustable base

CONS:

  • Can’t adjust handle w/ canopy up
  • Support cushions are too tight

​Conclusion

My recommendations for the best infant car seats for small cars would be the Britax B-Safe 35 for a carrier car seat and the Safety First Guide 65 for a convertible car seat.

These two, in particular, are some of the narrowest models on the market making them the most ideal for small cars. Both have great safety features and are usable with infants starting from 4 to 5 pounds. They are also affordable for just about any family’s budget.

Do you have a car seat you recommend for a small car? Be sure to share your recommendation with us and others.

 

Last update on 2018-09-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment